all 5 original members at rarhof and talk of cd followup

[insides]

who wouldn't want a reunion between the original members? don't tell me that you prefer the new band? they're just a bunch of hired hands whilst only Axl and Dizzy remain from the days of the classic GNR lineup. honestly, who is the first guitarist that you think of when you think of Guns N' Roses? do you think of Robin, Buckethead, DJ Ashba, Richard or fuckin' Paul Tobias? No, you think of Slash and usually Izzy too (fuck Gilby, he was also a hired hand). Would the first bass player come to mind as Tommy Stinson? No, you'd usually think of Duff as the bass player (although I respect Tommy). Which drummer do you think of when you think of Guns N' Roses? it probably isn't Frank (the body guard looking guy) or Brain (the other guy), most likely it'd be either Steven or Matt.

So when almost anybody thinks about Guns N' Roses, they have their mind set on Axl, Slash, Duff, Izzy, Steven (or Matt) and sometimes Dizzy. but usually it's the classic 5 piece from the '80s that most everybody thinks of and it's that lineup that wrote the classic Appetite For Destruction album and the reason why GNR is inducted into the Rock and Roll Hall of Fame and that's why Axl, Slash, Izzy, Duff, Steven, Matt and Dizzy are the members being inducted. Robin, Buckethead, Paul Tobais, Richard, DJ, Tommy, Chris, Frank, Bumblefoot, Brain, and the rest of the members/ex members are not being inducted because they did not create the music that GNR is most well known for! Honestly (and seriously), did any of you on here discover GNR after listening to Chinese Democracy? No, for the most part, nobody has discovered the band through CD. They discovered them by listening to Appetite, Lies and the Illusion records.

So what is GNR all about?
The ones who created the music that GNR is well known for and what most fans want most:
Axl, Slash, Izzy, Duff and Steven
I rest my case

i prefer robin, bucket, and brain coming back. so there unreleased chinese songs get released on the next chinese record

and a reunion would ruin that. a reunion would ruin future chinese records coming out

i don't live in the past. i live for the future. a reunion would destroy the future

[rocknroll41]

i prefer robin, bucket, and brain coming back. so there unreleased chinese songs get released on the next chinese record

and a reunion would ruin that. a reunion would ruin future chinese records coming out

i don't live in the past. i live for the future. a reunion would destroy the future

look bro, I understand your argument. its not like you're the only one who prefers current GnR, but this is the RHOF we're talking about and the band that made it possible is the band that's going in and they should all be there for the sake of us fans that want it to be that way instead of a Van Halen scenario. What they choose to do after that is anyone's guess, really. Maybe they will release more music from the current line-up, who knows. but as far as the RHOF goes, the hundreds, maybe even thousands, of fans around the world (including me) should get a nice ceremony. A performance of any kind would be killer, too. If any other band that gets inducted has the right to perform than so does GnR, no matter what the circumstances are.

[GnR587]

a reunion would destroy the future

-1

[cn'd05]

It would be sweet if they play at the RnRHoF which I think they will, be even sweeter if they hit the studio n gave the fans a mini ep or something, 3-5 songs, then I could die peacefully..

[insides]

look bro, I understand your argument. its not like you're the only one who prefers current GnR, but this is the RHOF we're talking about and the band that made it possible is the band that's going in and they should all be there for the sake of us fans that want it to be that way instead of a Van Halen scenario. What they choose to do after that is anyone's guess, really. Maybe they will release more music from the current line-up, who knows. but as far as the RHOF goes, the hundreds, maybe even thousands, of fans around the world (including me) should get a nice ceremony. A performance of any kind would be killer, too. If any other band that gets inducted has the right to perform than so does GnR, no matter what the circumstances are.

i know what the HOF is. axl rose and bruce springsteen performed come together at the HOF

but this HOF will get in the way of the release of the next chinese record in 2012

i don't support that. i don't support reunion. reunion kills future chinese releases

[snakepipero]

who wouldn't want a reunion between the original members? don't tell me that you prefer the new band? they're just a bunch of hired hands whilst only Axl and Dizzy remain from the days of the classic GNR lineup. honestly, who is the first guitarist that you think of when you think of Guns N' Roses? do you think of Robin, Buckethead, DJ Ashba, Richard or fuckin' Paul Tobias? No, you think of Slash and usually Izzy too (fuck Gilby, he was also a hired hand). Would the first bass player come to mind as Tommy Stinson? No, you'd usually think of Duff as the bass player (although I respect Tommy). Which drummer do you think of when you think of Guns N' Roses? it probably isn't Frank (the body guard looking guy) or Brain (the other guy), most likely it'd be either Steven or Matt.

So when almost anybody thinks about Guns N' Roses, they have their mind set on Axl, Slash, Duff, Izzy, Steven (or Matt) and sometimes Dizzy. but usually it's the classic 5 piece from the '80s that most everybody thinks of and it's that lineup that wrote the classic Appetite For Destruction album and the reason why GNR is inducted into the Rock and Roll Hall of Fame and that's why Axl, Slash, Izzy, Duff, Steven, Matt and Dizzy are the members being inducted. Robin, Buckethead, Paul Tobais, Richard, DJ, Tommy, Chris, Frank, Bumblefoot, Brain, and the rest of the members/ex members are not being inducted because they did not create the music that GNR is most well known for! Honestly (and seriously), did any of you on here discover GNR after listening to Chinese Democracy? No, for the most part, nobody has discovered the band through CD. They discovered them by listening to Appetite, Lies and the Illusion records.

So what is GNR all about?
The ones who created the music that GNR is well known for and what most fans want most:
Axl, Slash, Izzy, Duff and Steven
I rest my case

[snakepipero]

i know what the HOF is. axl rose and bruce springsteen performed come together at the HOF

but this HOF will get in the way of the release of the next chinese record in 2012

i don't support that. i don't support reunion.

[insides]

the next batch is ready. recorded. the HOF will prevent its release. HOF will probably lead to reunion and that's it for chinese

[rocknroll41]

the next batch is ready. recorded. the HOF will prevent its release. HOF will probably lead to reunion and that's it for chinese

What the fuck are you talking about?

Dizzy and Tommy both said that the band still has studio work to do. They even said the Chinese reject tracks still aren't finished yet. Tommy even once said Axl still needs to add vocals. I'm pretty sure the reason nothing is out is cause NOTHING is ready yet.

Dizzy said the band might go into the studio after this Up Close & Personal tour in the US is done, but think about it. Do you seriously think the band is going to be able to finish recording and mixing a whole record in time for that summer Europe tour? Especially when Dizzy, Tommy, Dj and Bumblefoot have made it clear that they want at least some of the songs on it to be new songs that are still in the writing stages as far as we know.

Don't get me wrong, I'm not an insider and I don't know what's really going on, but I'm pretty sure no matter what happens at the RHOF, the new album is still far away. I'd like to be proven wrong, though.

As far as the HOF leading to a full-time reunion, doubt it. But we'll see

[insides]

What the fuck are you talking about?

Dizzy and Tommy both said that the band still has studio work to do. They even said the Chinese reject tracks still aren't finished yet. Tommy even once said Axl still needs to add vocals. I'm pretty sure the reason nothing is out is cause NOTHING is ready yet.

Dizzy said the band might go into the studio after this Up Close & Personal tour in the US is done, but think about it. Do you seriously think the band is going to be able to finish recording and mixing a whole record in time for that summer Europe tour? Especially when Dizzy, Tommy, Dj and Bumblefoot have made it clear that they want at least some of the songs on it to be new songs that are still in the writing stages as far as we know.

Don't get me wrong, I'm not an insider and I don't know what's really going on, but I'm pretty sure no matter what happens at the RHOF, the new album is still far away. I'd like to be proven wrong, though.

As far as the HOF leading to a full-time reunion, doubt it. But we'll see

dizzy and tommy r sayin that to buy time for the classics hits tour and HOF. the tracks r done. they were done before robin wasn't in the band anymore

dj and bumblefoot r sayin what they r cause they don't want the songs recorded by robin and bucket on the next record. they want their own stuff instead

the tracks r done. the next chinese record is ready for release 

[shackler in the rye]

dizzy and tommy r sayin that to buy time for the classics hits tour and HOF. the tracks r done. they were done before robin wasn't in the band anymore

dj and bumblefoot r sayin what they r cause they don't want the songs recorded by robin and bucket on the next record. they want their own stuff instead

the tracks r done. the next chinese record is ready for release 

How do you know the reasons for what bumblefoot and dj say?
and why in all your posts do you refer to the next album as the next "chinese record"?

[rocknroll41]

dizzy and tommy r sayin that to buy time for the classics hits tour and HOF. the tracks r done. they were done before robin wasn't in the band anymore

dj and bumblefoot r sayin what they r cause they don't want the songs recorded by robin and bucket on the next record. they want their own stuff instead

the tracks r done. the next chinese record is ready for release 

what's the classics hits tour? are you talking about the current tour?

[insides]

what's the classics hits tour? are you talking about the current tour?

the current tour is the classic hits tour. the tour axl did in 2011. it's the current tour happening now. right into the HOF

[GnFnRosesfan#1]

i prefer robin, bucket, and brain coming back. so there unreleased chinese songs get released on the next chinese record

and a reunion would ruin that. a reunion would ruin future chinese records coming out

i don't live in the past. i live for the future. a reunion would destroy the future

You dont live in the past but you want three ex members back in the band? What kind of sense doesthat make? So for us that want the classic line up for at least one show is living in the past, but you want the 2001 line up, so thats living in the future? Hmmm.
Give me axl, slash, izzy, duff, dizzy, and whomever on drums or give me the current lineup. You can keep anything from 2000-2008, thats how ifeel.

[GnFnRosesfan#1]

Every site needs a new whipping boy, batter up insides!!!