Since I am fair, I will judge them all equally. Finck messes up the fast part of the solo, other than that he does good.
Ashba does a great job, but he doesnt do the dificult part of the solo, so its hard to judge him.
Bumblefoot does a great job on the fast part, sounds pretty damn good to me.
Slash, well what can I say? He is prolly high and drunk and still sounds note for note with whats on the album
What does everyone else thknk? Watch the videos,and judge for yourself.