I listened to Chi Dem in the car yesterday, and fucking loved it. It does have points I'm not so keen on, but all the songs there are strong, and some are epic. TWAT still gives me goosebumps for God's sake. I might have ripped on the band, but shit, they can't half write some cool shit. I love how it's different, not only to old Guns, but to everything else out there too. Bucket's weirdness combined with Finck's more normal guitar parts with the extra awesome provided by Pitman really makes it a great album. One of my favourites actually, now I think of it.
And so I say I disagree with this man. It's just a shame I don't get paid to write my opinion on the interwebs and have other people read it.